Skip to main content

Why Tony Stewart isn't likely to face charges in racetrack death

By Paul Callan, CNN Legal Analyst
August 12, 2014 -- Updated 1220 GMT (2020 HKT)
Driver Tony Stewart looks on in the garage area during practice for the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Cheez-It 355 at Watkins Glen International on Friday, August 8, in Watkins Glen, New York. Stewart is a three-time champion in NASCAR's top division and also won a sprint car championship in 1995. Driver Tony Stewart looks on in the garage area during practice for the NASCAR Sprint Cup Series Cheez-It 355 at Watkins Glen International on Friday, August 8, in Watkins Glen, New York. Stewart is a three-time champion in NASCAR's top division and also won a sprint car championship in 1995.
HIDE CAPTION
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
Racer Tony Stewart
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
>
>>
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NASCAR driver Tony Stewart's car hit and killed driver Kevin Ward Jr. during race
  • Paul Callan: Sheriff likely to look at Stewart's bad boy image and amateur video of crash
  • Callan: Still, sheriff says, no evidence of criminal intent on Stewart's part
  • Callan: Ward recklessly walked onto track; Stewart had right to think that would not happen

Editor's note: Paul Callan, a CNN legal analyst, is a former New York homicide prosecutor and a senior partner at Callan, Koster, Brady and Brennan, LLP. Follow him on Twitter @PaulCallan. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author.

(CNN) -- Even hardened race fans, accustomed to witnessing spectacular crashes, were stunned to see the shattered body of 20-year-old race car driver Kevin Ward Jr. sprawled on a New York dirt track Saturday night.

He had been run over and killed by a car driven by Tony Stewart, one of the most famous, charismatic and controversial drivers on the $3 billion-per-year NASCAR race circuit. Much of the public's interest in Stewart undoubtedly derives, not only from his winning record but also from his tough guy, bad boy image reminiscent of the sport's early rough-and-tumble days.

Paul Callan
Paul Callan

That image will certainly be one of the things authorities in New York will be looking at when trying to decide whether to close this case as a tragic accident or to press forward with criminal charges.

The preliminary signals from the Ontario County Sheriff's Office would indicate a favorable outcome for Stewart. Sheriff Philip Povero has announced that the Ward tragedy is viewed as an "on track crash," and that to date there was no evidence of "criminal intent." The sheriff did hedge a bit by saying that the "investigation was continuing."

The sheriff has undoubtedly been carefully reviewing the amateur video of the crash. It depicts Stewart's car in close proximity to Ward's car coming out of Turn 2 in the race. Ward's car then appears to be pushed into the outside wall, forcing his car out of the race.

Ward then appears to exit his vehicle angrily and charges on to the racetrack, pointing in the direction of Stewart's and other drivers' swiftly approaching cars. In graphic and stunning video footage, young Ward is hit, apparently by the right rear tire of Stewart's vehicle, causing him to be dragged down the track to his death.

We can expect that Povero will continue his investigation by interviewing witnesses and undoubtedly obtaining copies of other videos taken from different angles. He will likely consult with experts in racing.

NASCAR's Tony Stewart hits, kills driver
Sheriff: 'There's much work to be done'
Will Stewart face criminal charges?

His key questions: 1. Was Ward's decision to stand in the track, so close to moving vehicles unusual? 2. Should Stewart, knowing he may have struck Ward's car, have anticipated a problem when approaching the turn as a "yellow flag" had been thrown warning drivers to proceed cautiously as an accident or debris ahead was likely?

Povero will be working in close conjunction with the Ontario County District Attorney, R. Michael Tantillo, a seven-term veteran of criminal investigations and trials. Tantillo supervises a staff of about 10 attorneys that serves a county with a population of about 107,000 residents.

New York, on average, prosecutes 5% of vehicular accident death cases as criminal matters. Most cases are viewed as tragic accidents caused by either driver or pedestrian negligence. Cases prosecuted criminally usually involve charges of drunken or drugged driving. So far no allegations of intoxicated driving have emerged in the Stewart/Ward investigation.

In this case it will be impossible to know what was going through Stewart's mind as he approached the Ward vehicle under the warning of a yellow flag. To prosecute this case as an intentional murder or even as a more serious form of manslaughter, there would have to be proof that Stewart "intentionally" aimed his car at Ward seeking to kill or injure him seriously.

Stewart's intent here is impossible to prove regardless of his bad boy reputation unless he were to confess to an intentional murder. I think it's safe to say that is not going to happen.

Prosecutors will next examine whether Stewart operated his vehicle with "depraved indifference," "recklessness" or "criminal negligence" at the track that night. Evidence of such conduct would be necessary to support any nonintentional murder, manslaughter or criminally negligent homicide charge.

The evidence supporting criminal charges is conspicuously absent given what we now know about the case. Ward recklessly choose to walk into an active and highly dangerous racetrack exposing himself to injury or death. An experienced professional driver such as Stewart had a right to expect that his fellow drivers would conduct themselves in a safe and professional manner during the race.

Collisions are a common part of the race scene, and one would expect a driver in Ward's vulnerable position to get off the track and out of harm's way immediately. Stewart was, no doubt, shocked to see Ward in the roadway pointing in his direction as he approached the turn again. In fact, Stewart's car appears to fishtail slightly, indicating an attempt to avoid contact with Ward.

In determining whether Stewart's conduct was reckless or criminally negligent, the conduct of the other drivers in the race will be examined. They appear to be proceeding at a similar speed as Stewart under the yellow flag warning. They too were probably surprised to see Ward positioned in such a dangerous place.

The evidence supporting criminal charges is just not here. In the end, all signs point to a red flag for any criminal charges against Stewart in this tragic accident arising from America's most popular summer sport.

Read CNNOpinion's new Flipboard magazine

Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion.

Join us on Facebook.com/CNNOpinion.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Tony Stewart
August 11, 2014 -- Updated 1600 GMT (0000 HKT)
Although NASCAR driver Tony Stewart is not currently facing criminal charges in the death of another driver, he is not officially in the clear.
August 12, 2014 -- Updated 1704 GMT (0104 HKT)
Kevin Ward Jr. died of "massive blunt trauma" when Tony Stewart hit him with his sprint car.
August 12, 2014 -- Updated 1549 GMT (2349 HKT)
As soon as he could, Kevin Ward Jr. got in a race car. As soon as he could, Kevin Ward Jr. started winning races.
August 16, 2014 -- Updated 2119 GMT (0519 HKT)
After the death of Kevin Ward Jr., NASCAR has made a new rule against drivers exiting vehicles. Alexandra Field reports.
August 12, 2014 -- Updated 1414 GMT (2214 HKT)
Tony Stewart's profession is driving for millions of dollars a year in NASCAR races, but his hobby is racing against amateurs on dirt tracks for trophies.
Emotions play a big part in racing. The fans expect it. They want that emotion-fueled, adrenaline pumping, heart-stopping, side-by-side action.
August 14, 2014 -- Updated 1800 GMT (0200 HKT)
Two dirt-track racers explain the appeal of the sport and give their opinions on the fatal wreck involving Tony Stewart.
August 12, 2014 -- Updated 1220 GMT (2020 HKT)
Even hardened race fans, accustomed to witnessing spectacular crashes, were stunned to see the shattered body of 20-year-old race car driver Kevin Ward Jr. sprawled on a New York dirt track.
August 10, 2014 -- Updated 1747 GMT (0147 HKT)
A look at recent highlights from racer Tony Stewart's career.
August 14, 2014 -- Updated 1257 GMT (2057 HKT)
Andy Scholes speaks with 25-year dirt track racing veteran, Danny Smith, to learn more about the popular sport.
August 11, 2014 -- Updated 2217 GMT (0617 HKT)
With his history of violent incidents, why was NASCAR's Tony Stewart even allowed to race? CNN's Rachel Nichols reports.
ADVERTISEMENT