Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

What sports capitalism can teach us about real world fair play

By Stefan Szymanski, Special to CNN
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1558 GMT (2358 HKT)
For the ninth straight year Real Madrid are ranked as the world's richest club with a total revenue of $702 million. Their global reach allows the Spanish club to make millions in commercial revenue, both domestically and internationally, thanks to marketable stars like Cristiano Ronaldo -- recently crowned the world's best player. For the ninth straight year Real Madrid are ranked as the world's richest club with a total revenue of $702 million. Their global reach allows the Spanish club to make millions in commercial revenue, both domestically and internationally, thanks to marketable stars like Cristiano Ronaldo -- recently crowned the world's best player.
HIDE CAPTION
Football's Rich List: 1. Real Madrid
2. Barcelona
3. Bayern Munich
4. Manchester United
5. Paris Saint-Germain
6. Manchester City
7. Chelsea
8. Arsenal
9. Juventus
10. AC Milan
11. Borussia Dortmund
12. Liverpool
13. Schalke 04
14. Tottenham Hotspur
15. Internazionale
16. Galatasaray
17. Hamburg SV
18. Fenerbahce
19. AS Roma
20. Atletico Madrid
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
>
>>
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Sport is big business, but commercialism is a relatively recent phenomenon
  • Sport capitalism comes in two models: That used in America, and in Europe
  • But operate very differently but the players do extremely well, Stefan Szymanski says
  • And professional sport must be considered a successful form of modern capitalism

Editor's note: Stefan Szymanski is the Stephen J. Galetti Professor of Sport Management at the University of Michigan. Prior to that he was a professor of economics at business schools in London for over 20 years. He is the author a numerous academic articles on the economics of sport, and co-author (with Simon Kuper) of the NY Times bestseller Soccernomics, on which he also blogs. Follow him on Twitter. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Stefan Szymanski.

(CNN) -- That sport has become a big business is a well-worn cliche. It also widely acknowledged that commercialism in sport is relatively recent phenomenon.

Fifty years ago the majority of sports were organized on amateur lines, and even in professional sports the sums of money at stake were negligible.

Commercial sport has become one of the most visible manifestations of globalization, with broadcasting and sponsorships turning clubs and players into vehicles for generating cash -- some consider them more brands than athletes.

Stefan Szymanski
Stefan Szymanski

So how is all this working out -- for the sports organizations, the players, and the fans? And in this time of crisis, what can this microcosm of capitalism teach the economics of the real world?

Textbook economics teaches that woes of capitalism can be identified with two problems: The failure to achieve truly competitive markets and the manifest unreasonableness of the initial distribution of income.

Markets fail to be competitive because of various manifestations of monopoly power, often associated with superior access to relevant information, whereas efforts to improve the perceived fairness of the income distribution often conflict with the objective of improving economic efficiency.

Markets fail to be competitive because of various manifestations of monopoly power
Stefan Szymanski

Sports capitalism has some unique characteristics.

First, monopoly will not work -- teams and athletes need sporting competitors. Second, those competitors need to be genuine, in the sense that there is some degree of balance -- a predictable contest has limited entertainment value.

There are essentially two approaches to organizing competition: The American model and the European model.

The American model works like this. A collection of businessmen agree to found a league, each operating a franchise which is responsible for managing a team, securing a stadium and selling tickets.

Soccer player gets $132 million paycheck
Honeymoon over for Gareth Bale, Madrid

The league, meaning owners operating as a committee, manage several important issues centrally. Typically, the broadcast rights are sold collectively, and often the merchandising rights too, with the money to be equally shared between the teams.

Visiting teams may be given a share of the gate. The league negotiates centrally with a players' union, fixing both minimum and maximum salaries.

No club is allowed to spend too much more than anyone else, and the weakest teams are typically rewarded with the first choice of new players entering the league (the draft).

In essence, the league is run as a kind of socialist collective by the franchise owners. And this model has been colossally successful in generating profits over the last 50 years.

In 2012 a study by WR Hambrecht estimated the market value of the four major leagues (NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL) at $67 billion. Collectivism seems to work.

The leagues argue that their success can be attributed to the rules which maintain balance among the teams. Skeptics argue that the economic success derives from artificial scarcity (entry into the majors is closely restricted) and monopoly power (these are the best leagues in the world in their sports -- the potential for new entrants to become rivals is negligible).

Commercial sport has become one of the most visible manifestations of globalization
Stefan Szymanski

Sports in Europe is dominated by soccer, which operates under a completely different business model.

From an economic perspective there is free entry, in the sense that anyone can start a team and enter at the lowest league level, and then work their way to the top purely on sporting merit.

This is because each league in a given country is connected to every other league through the promotion and relegation system. This specifies that at the end of the season the worst performing teams (in sporting teams) and sent down to play in the next league down (relegation), whose best teams replace them (promotion).

This fluidity promotes a kind of cutthroat competition, where collective agreements are very limited. The threat of relegation means that the strong are not willing to share with the weak.

Qatar's World Cup hosting in jeopardy?
Platini outlines UEFA's racism reforms

Perhaps surprisingly, the European model is one of pure capitalist competition, red in tooth and claw. Profitability is very low.

According to a study published by UEFA, the European governing body of soccer, in 2012, out of 700 clubs operating in the top divisions in European countries, 63% reported an operating loss, 55% reported a net loss, 38% reported negative net equity and auditors raised "going concern" doubts in 16% of cases.

European leagues are also highly unequal in sporting terms, with a handful of clubs dominating competition at both national and European level.

Many believe that the system is not stable, and UEFA has recently introduced regulations in order to achieve a less economically competitive environment.

Many people feel it unfair that nurses or firemen earn small salaries compared to sports stars, but their pay simply reflects scarcity
Stefan Szymanski

However, as a system European football has been remarkably stable, with few clubs being liquidated, and a succession of "sugar daddies" being willing to step in and finance loss making clubs because of the prestige that this brings.

In both systems the players have done extremely well.

In the U.S. the unions have secured guaranteed percentages of league revenues, while in Europe open competition has ensured that wages have been bid up.

Top players earns tens of millions in salaries and even more from endorsements. Almost every school age child nowadays yearns to be a top athlete.

Many people feel it unfair that nurses or firemen earn small salaries compared to sports stars, but their pay simply reflects scarcity. The best are able to perform athletically in ways that no else can, in order to win championships on which fans place enormous value.

And do the fans do well? It sometimes seems that the default mode of the fan is discontent, with a jealous eye constantly turned to past in which life was simpler and tickets were cheaper.

Eto'o: Money doesn't motivate me
Pitfalls of the premier football leagues

There are constant scandals concerning the abuse of drugs, violence on and off the field, match fixing and gambling, exploitation of fans through ever increasing ticket prices. But the fact is that the universe of fans has expanded dramatically over the last fifty years, attendances have grown to unprecedented levels and broadcasting has ensured that any sporting event can be viewed anywhere in the world.

In this sense at least, modern professional sport, whether along the social-democratic lines adopted in the U.S., or the bare-knuckle laissez version practised in Europe, must be considered one of the most successful manifestations of modern capitalism.

Read more:

Fair play? Football clubs seek to beat financial offside trap

Postcard from America: Does sport need a soundtrack?

The next David Beckham: When Hollywood meets sport

Real Madrid named 'most valuable sports team'

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Stefan Szymanski.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
January 27, 2014 -- Updated 1714 GMT (0114 HKT)
The World Economic Forum in Davos was a missed opportunity to start real dialogue and must change if it is to stay relevant, argues Richard Quest
January 27, 2014 -- Updated 1700 GMT (0100 HKT)
Nina dos Santos was in Davos interviewing world leaders by day, mingling at the parties of millionaires by night. So what are they really like?
January 28, 2014 -- Updated 0902 GMT (1702 HKT)
The World Economic Forum usually attracts protesters but this year's were very quiet. So why were they there?
January 25, 2014 -- Updated 1419 GMT (2219 HKT)
IMF chief Christine Lagarde says governments should beware of the global deflation genie coming out of its bottle.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1136 GMT (1936 HKT)
A relentless quest for share price boosts can result in disastrous long-term results, writes Andre Spicer.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1753 GMT (0153 HKT)
Actress Goldie Hawn says CEOs are discovering how to cope with stress and make better decisions .
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 2207 GMT (0607 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon about the progress being made in establishing Syrian peace.
January 25, 2014 -- Updated 1658 GMT (0058 HKT)
selfie Richard Quest
Selfie is the word du jour and CNN's Richard Quest set himself a selfie challenge, but which VIPs agreed to pose?
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 0931 GMT (1731 HKT)
Israel's President points a finger at Iran over the carnage in Syria, due to support for Shiite militant group Hezbollah.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 0755 GMT (1555 HKT)
World Bank chief Jim Yong Kim calls for a concerted global effort to help Syria's refugees, saying the response so far has been inadequate.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 2206 GMT (0606 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu about why cyber security is so important to the Israeli economy.
Think you're paid what you're worth? Explore how your wage compares to the average in your country, then see where you sit globally.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 2225 GMT (0625 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest speaks to Cantor Fitzgerald CEO Howard Lutnick about the lack of a crisis at Davos 2014.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 2213 GMT (0613 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to the OECD's Angel Gurria on how inequality and lack of economic growth are tied together.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 1910 GMT (0310 HKT)
It's town of cuckoo clocks, $20 pasta and very slippery pavements -- tread carefully, warns first-timer Chris Pepper.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 1920 GMT (0320 HKT)
Nina dos Santos speaks to former U.S. Treasury Sec. Larry Summers who says public sector investment should be encouraged.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 0949 GMT (1749 HKT)
Almost 40 years and trillions worth of GDP after Mao, an entire generation still has little idea of what kind of nation to strive for, writes Damien Ma.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1518 GMT (2318 HKT)
CNN anchors Richard Quest and Nina dos Santos disagree as to whether this meeting of power players can make a difference to global inequality.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 0517 GMT (1317 HKT)
The crisis in Syria was front and center for the movers and shakers as Davos formally got underway.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1641 GMT (0041 HKT)
Richard Quest heads to Davos, where everyone, it seems, has an event they want him to attend. Read his view of the parties.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 2204 GMT (0604 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to European Commission Pres. Jose Manuel Barroso about what can be done about the Ukrainian protests.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 0818 GMT (1618 HKT)
Egypt has entrusted its democracy to the army, the police, a disempowered political class, writes Aalam Wassef.
Answer 4 questions to tell us if your mood is up or down, and see how others are responding.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 2301 GMT (0701 HKT)
Speaking at the WEF in Davos, Japanese PM Shinzo Abe said that by 2020 women occupy 30% of leadership positions.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1546 GMT (2346 HKT)
Norway's Crown Prince Haakon says it is dangerous not to let youth help reshape the world, as they have the resources to act.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1503 GMT (2303 HKT)
Three years after the Arab Spring, its issues are back on the agenda and Syrian peace talks have begun. A Tunisian writer says little has changed.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1915 GMT (0315 HKT)
Ostentation-adverse Pope Francis has some serious cards to lay on the table in the game of global economic reform, writes John Allen.
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1758 GMT (0158 HKT)
The World Economic Forum is not just a global gabfest. History is often made there, as Nina Dos Santos reports.
January 20, 2014 -- Updated 1251 GMT (2051 HKT)
We need to invest in human capital to combat a predatory capitalist system, argues Anne-Marie Slaughter.
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1304 GMT (2104 HKT)
today's emerging markets can be divided into the tortoises and hares, CNN's John Defterios writes. But which will win 2014?
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1030 GMT (1830 HKT)
CNN's Isa Soares talks to chef Alexandre Kroll about the challenges of cooking for the world's financial leaders in Davos.
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1159 GMT (1959 HKT)
Why would a young person with a job, or in education, or training, want to riot and loot, when they have a stake in the future?
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1929 GMT (0329 HKT)
The small Swiss town of Davos readies for its annual onslaught of world leaders and power players.
January 20, 2014 -- Updated 1552 GMT (2352 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest says growing income inequality will be high on the agenda at the World Economic Forum.
January 17, 2014 -- Updated 1115 GMT (1915 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest ponders whether he's climbing a Swiss mountain to learn the meaning of "heterarchy."
January 19, 2014 -- Updated 1214 GMT (2014 HKT)
What will business leaders, heads of government, entrepreneurs and celebrities discuss in Davos?
January 20, 2014 -- Updated 1726 GMT (0126 HKT)
Davos is invitation-only, but even if you made the cut, could you afford the entry fee? And once there, what do you need to do to fit in?
ADVERTISEMENT