Skip to main content

Iran nuclear deal shows hawks that diplomacy actually works

By Bryan R. Gibson, special for CNN
November 25, 2013 -- Updated 1337 GMT (2137 HKT)
Chief negotiator Catherine Ashton and Iran's foreign minister announce agreement on Iran's nuclear program early on Sunday, November 24 in Geneva. Chief negotiator Catherine Ashton and Iran's foreign minister announce agreement on Iran's nuclear program early on Sunday, November 24 in Geneva.
Iran nuclear deal reached
Iran nuclear deal reached
Iran nuclear deal reached
Iran nuclear deal reached
Iran nuclear deal reached
  • The Iran deal is progress in the reconciliation between Iran and the U.S, writes Bryan R. Gibson
  • This is Obama's "opening to China" moment and he must seize it, he writes
  • He says: When Barack Obama came to office there was hope he could achieve a breakthrough
  • The election of Rouhani in June 2013 has turned U.S.-Iranian relations on its head, he writes

Editor's note: Bryan R. Gibson is the Pinto Post-Doctoral Fellow at LSE IDEAS. He is the author of "Covert Relationship: U.S. Foreign Policy, Intelligence and the Iran-Iraq War."

(CNN) -- The deal struck at the weekend between Iran and world powers over its nuclear program is not just a triumph of Western diplomacy, but a step forward in the budding rapprochement between Iran and the U.S. that had been long in the making.

Every U.S. administration from Reagan to Obama has tried to reach out to Iran. Unfortunately, these efforts all failed because the circumstances for rapprochement were not quite right -- unlike today, where Iran's new president, Hassan Rouhani, has been determined to outflank his ideological opponents in Tehran and reach a deal with the West.

Bryan R. Gibson
Bryan R. Gibson

The Obama administration seems equally determined -- despite opposition from Saudi Arabia and Israel, as well as an obstructive Congress -- to welcome the Iranians back into the international community, so long as they agree to play by the rules.

This is Obama's "opening to China" moment and he must seize it.

Ever since Iranian students stormed the U.S. Embassy in Tehran on November 4, 1979 and initiated the 444-day Iran-hostage crisis, the United States and Iran have been regional arch-nemeses. Even so, in the thirty years since this traumatic event, there have been periodic efforts to improve relations.

Israel's displeasure in nuclear deal
Breaking down Iran's nuclear deal
Iran looks for easing sanctions on oil

The first episode occurred in 1985 when Israeli officials helped facilitate a back-channel approach to so-called Iranian "moderates", represented by Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani. This led to the infamous "Mission to Tehran", where senior U.S. officials traveled to Tehran to trade weapons and spare parts in exchange for the release of American hostages held in Lebanon. This mission failed spectacularly. Details were leaked to the press, leading to the Iran-Contra scandal, which nearly brought the Reagan administration down.

After George H.W. Bush's election in 1988, the U.S. reached out to Iran once again, saying in his inaugural address, "Goodwill begets goodwill". Bush implied that if the Iranian regime helped the U.S. obtain the release of the hostages, he would respond with gestures of goodwill.

Upon Rafsanjani's election as president in June 1989, he announced that he would help the U.S. obtain the release of the hostages, which was done in late 1991. But goodwill did not beget goodwill. When the hostages were released, the U.S. did not do anything.

During Clinton's first term, U.S.-Iranian relations first underwent a deep chill. Following the Gulf War, the U.S. sought to "contain" Iran and Iraq, even though Iran had disarmed itself following the Iran-Iraq War. The policy, known as "Dual Containment", was confusing. It advocated America playing a costly balancing role, when in fact the U.S. needed Iran to balance Iraq and vice versa. But the landslide election of Mohammad Khatami in 1997 led to a major thaw in U.S.-Iranian relations.

Like Rouhani today, Khatami sought to open up to the U.S., telling CNN that "all doors should now be open for such dialogue and understanding and the possibility for contact between Iranian and American citizens." Clinton seized this opportunity and exchanged letters with the Iranians in 1999, but regime hardliners undercut Khatami and rejected the American overture.

Iranian's react to nuclear deal
Analysis: Nuclear deal with Iran
What Iran nuclear deal reveals

After the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, the Iranian people -- much to the surprise of U.S. officials -- poured into the streets in solidarity with the American people. As U.S. officials prepared for war they were shocked to find Iran ready to help. According to Bruce Reidel, a former U.S. official, the U.S. and Iran worked closely together after the toppling of the Taliban to establish the post-war Afghan government. Unfortunately, George W. Bush squandered whatever goodwill had been achieved by including Iran as part of the so-called "Axis of Evil. »

Even so, the U.S. still made progress on the nuclear issue. In May 2003, Iran sought to trade Western acceptance of its right to a peaceful nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief, assistance in stabilizing Iraq, and cooperation against al-Qaeda. But the U.S. rejected Iran's proposal, undermined the Khatami government, and ruined any chance of achieving a lasting deal.

When Barack Obama came to office in 2009 there was great optimism that he could achieve a major breakthrough. This was because Obama had indicated during his election campaign that he was willing to talk directly with Iran. In March 2009, Obama sought to bolster moderates inside Iran in the lead up to the June 2009 election by speaking directly to the Iranian people.

Unfortunately, the regime's hardliners had no interest in seeing another reformist return to power and rigged the election, crushed the civic-minded protests against the regime, and ushered in another four year term for Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

The election of Rouhani in June 2013 has turned U.S.-Iranian relations on its head. Like Khatami in 1997, Rouhani stunned the West with a charm offensive, condemning Syria's use of chemical weapons, wishing Jews a happy Rosh Hashana, and releasing political prisoners. Rouhani's objective was clear: he wanted sanctions relief in exchange for a compromise over his country's nuclear program.

To this end, he found a willing partner in Obama. This remarkable opening culminated in Obama's famous telephone call to Rouhani at the end of the UN General Assembly in late-September, the first direct communication between American and Iranian leaders since 1979.

These exchanges set the stage for the nuclear deal reached over the weekend. After decades of intense hostility between the U.S. and Iran, calmer heads have finally prevailed.

Only time will tell if the U.S. and Iran can build upon this interim agreement and establish a working relationship, which is in the best interests of the region. More importantly, this deal stands as a lesson to the war hawks that diplomacy actually works.

READ: Will Iran deal unleash the 'Germany of the Middle East'?

READ: 20 questions about the Iran nuclear deal

INTERACTIVE: Nuclear weapons: Who has what?

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Bryan R. Gibson.

Part of complete coverage on
Iran nuclear deal
December 26, 2013 -- Updated 1040 GMT (1840 HKT)
Iranian lawmakers have drafted a bill that would force the government to enrich uranium up to 60% if new sanctions are imposed.
November 24, 2013 -- Updated 2131 GMT (0531 HKT)
Diplomats made history when Iran and six world powers came together on an agreement over Iran's nuclear program.
November 24, 2013 -- Updated 1635 GMT (0035 HKT)
The White House issued a detailed synopsis, or "fact sheet," of the six-month deal regarding Iran's nuclear program.
November 25, 2013 -- Updated 0245 GMT (1045 HKT)
A quick primer to get you up to speed on where we are and how we got there.
November 25, 2013 -- Updated 1337 GMT (2137 HKT)
The deal struck at the weekend is a step forward in the budding rapprochement between Iran and the U.S.
November 25, 2013 -- Updated 1559 GMT (2359 HKT)
While the EU and the U.St. cheered a deal that world powers reached with Tehran over its nuclear ambitions, Israel was fierce in its criticism.
November 24, 2013 -- Updated 1638 GMT (0038 HKT)
These are troubled times for President Barack Obama.
November 24, 2013 -- Updated 0419 GMT (1219 HKT)
U.S. President Barack Obama vows to "ratchet up the pressure" if Iran violates the nuclear deal.
November 24, 2013 -- Updated 0426 GMT (1226 HKT)
Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif says he hopes deal with improve Iran's relations with Western powers.
November 24, 2013 -- Updated 1351 GMT (2151 HKT)
Click through our gallery for an overview of how enriched uranium is made.
More than two dozen countries have nuclear power, but only a few have nuclear weapons or are suspected of pursuing nuclear weapons.
November 19, 2013 -- Updated 1619 GMT (0019 HKT)
Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Turkey as well as Israel all fear Iran gaining nuclear status, writes Barak Seener.
November 17, 2013 -- Updated 0004 GMT (0804 HKT)
Russia's foreign minister says the opportunity to bring about an end to a decade-long standoff is one that must not be passed up.