Skip to main content

Why I wouldn't want to be royal baby

By Simon Hooper, special to CNN
July 23, 2013 -- Updated 1546 GMT (2346 HKT)
Catherine has been closely watched throughout her pregnancy -- her new baby will be subject to similar scrutiny.
Catherine has been closely watched throughout her pregnancy -- her new baby will be subject to similar scrutiny.
  • All eyes have been on Duchess of Cambridge ahead of the birth of her first baby
  • Britain's royal family is closely watched by the media and the public
  • Simon Hooper: New royal should be "first to embrace the cause of republicanism"

Editor's note: Simon Hooper has worked as a journalist covering international news, politics and sports for websites and publications, including CNN, Al Jazeera, the New Statesman and Sports Illustrated.

London (CNN) -- As Britain segues seamlessly through feelgood summer heat from Andy Murray mania to royal baby euphoria, let us at least spare a thought for the unfortunate newborn caught, through no fault other than his ancestry, in the global spotlight.

No royal arrival has been so closely scrutinized since 1688 when Mary of Modena, wife of the widely disliked James II, gave birth watched by dozens of officials amid speculation that her pregnancy was a Catholic conspiracy intended to fabricate a male heir.

Even their presence was not enough to quash rumors that the child had been smuggled into the birthing chamber in a bedpan, and within months James had been deposed; his son was destined to spend his life in bitter exile in France and Rome.

Simon Hooper
Simon Hooper

At least the newborn prince and his parents are unlikely to be run out of the country, even if the flag-waving royalists celebrating the birth are hardly representative of a silent majority largely apathetic about the monarchy and more inclined to treat its modern incarnation as a publicly-subsidized soap opera largely staged for the amusement of American tourists.

'Wicked' author: Royal baby stands for hope

Nor did his mother suffer the indignity of having the home secretary in the vicinity of the delivery room, a custom for royal births only formally ended in 1948.

And there have undoubtedly been worse times in history to be born into one of Europe's great royal dynasties. Paris in 1789 springs to mind, or St. Petersburg in 1917.

Life for the Royal Baby
Britain's Baby Bash
Retailers see royal baby boost
Nursery fit for a monarch

Yet the life prospects of a boy now third in line to the British crown who, if as lucky in longevity as his paternal great-grandparents, might reasonably expect to see in the 22nd century on the throne, are hardly something to be envied.

The Windsors may have recovered some of their respectability after the nadir in their fortunes in the 1990s that culminated in the 1997 death of Princess Diana, thanks in no small part to the fairy-tale mega-wedding of William and Kate in 2011 and Oscar-winning propaganda such as "The Queen" and "The King's Speech."

To question the role of the monarchy and Britons' attachment to it is still to risk a public flogging from more reactionary sections of the British media, as author Hilary Mantel discovered when she found herself pilloried earlier this year for describing the Duchess of Cambridge as a "plastic princess designed to breed."

The resulting furore missed the point that Mantel was trying to make, which was that members of the royal family, however privileged and luxurious their lives, are essentially prisoners of their own circumstances, trapped by their supposed obligations to an archaic and largely redundant institution.

"Our current royal family doesn't have the difficulties in breeding that pandas do, but pandas and royal persons alike are expensive to conserve and ill-adapted to any modern environment. But aren't they interesting? Aren't they nice to look at?" said Mantel.

Opinion: Baby helps make a monarchy better

If Mantel's point was essentially true of Kate Middleton, who, like a mafia wife, married into the firm of her own volition, how much worse must the situation be for her offspring, who will become public property from the moment he is displayed to the assembled world media on the hospital steps.

Bookies offer odds on royal baby
Open Mic: Wishes, advice for Royal baby
Preparing for the royal baby

The mainstream media may feign responsibility, keeping a respectful distance as the young family find their feet and honoring royal requests to leave the child alone, but he will still face near constant public intrusion, living a life framed by the ubiquitous lens of the camera phone.

And in an age obsessed with the oxymoronic phenomena of "reality" and celebrity, the young royal will be forced to perform a gilded simulation of a normality that he will never experience for real, ultimately embracing the stiflingly conservatism of a British establishment of which the monarchy remains the apex, and allowing their personality to be airbrushed according to public tastes. It will be "The Truman Show" with footmen.

Royals, for better or worse, once inhabited worlds of intrigue, conspiracy and high drama, their lives, relationships and deaths entwined with the rise and fall of nations and empires. The feats and misdeeds of kings, queens and their progeny were fodder for Shakespearean epics.

Yet it is centuries since the British royal family played anything more than a decorative role in the life of the nation -- and this new heir may have to wait the best part of this century before assuming even those diminished duties.

Opinion: How to raise a royal baby

Royal heirs have traditionally passed the years waiting for their relatives to die by becoming champions of worthy causes. Prince Charles is famed for his woolly opinions on environmentalism and architecture, while Prince William has leant his support to the campaign to tackle homelessness.

Perhaps, out of enlightened self-interest alone and with time on his side, the prince could one day become the first royal to embrace the cause of republicanism.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Simon Hooper.

Part of complete coverage on
July 19, 2014 -- Updated 2149 GMT (0549 HKT)
Believe it or not, it has been almost a year since the birth of Prince George Alexander Louis. Here are 5 things to know about the youngster.
April 25, 2014 -- Updated 1629 GMT (0029 HKT)
Photos: Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, Prince William, Duke of Cambridge and Prince George of Cambridge embark on a Royal Tour.
April 7, 2014 -- Updated 1315 GMT (2115 HKT)
He can't even walk yet but Prince George took a momentous step on Monday in what's set to be a lifetime of royal duties.
June 16, 2014 -- Updated 1120 GMT (1920 HKT)
The first official images of Prince George are released, taken by his grandfather Michael Middleton in Berkshire, England.
July 23, 2013 -- Updated 1627 GMT (0027 HKT)
It's a boy! Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, and husband Prince William welcomed their first child - baby son.
July 17, 2013 -- Updated 2022 GMT (0422 HKT)
Think you know all you could ever want to about royal babies amid all the excitement about the new arrival? Well did you know this...
July 23, 2013 -- Updated 1546 GMT (2346 HKT)
The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, Prince William and his wife Kate are expecting their first baby, due in mid-July.
Let us least spare a thought for the unfortunate newborn caught, through no fault other than his ancestry, in the global spotlight, Simon Hooper writes.
July 5, 2013 -- Updated 0942 GMT (1742 HKT)
The royal family on the balcony at Buckingham Palace September 12, 1937 after the coronation of King George VI. King George VI (R) stands with Princess Elizabeth (C) and Princess Margaret.
Britain's royals are a pretty traditional bunch when it comes to picking baby names -- so what are the chances of a Queen Ella or King Terry?
Confused by who's linked to who in the royal family? Explore the Middleton and Windsor branches of our interactive family tree.
July 10, 2013 -- Updated 1604 GMT (0004 HKT)
Here's a look at some interesting statistics about royal births in Britain.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1358 GMT (2158 HKT)
As well as being wonderful news for the royal couple the new baby will have positive implications for the future of the UK monarchy.
August 7, 2014 -- Updated 2126 GMT (0526 HKT)
Prince William has spent decades in the public eye. Follow the royal's life in pictures, from baby to proud father-to-be.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1407 GMT (2207 HKT)
Changes to the law mean Prince William and Catherine's new baby will be heir to the British throne, whether it is a boy or a girl.
October 20, 2013 -- Updated 1214 GMT (2014 HKT)
Catherine has proved quite the fashionista since being catapulted into the limelight thanks to her appearance in a university catwalk show.
Get all the latest news, photos and videos on Kate and William's baby and the rest of the royal family.