Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on
 

Why life through Google Glass should be for our eyes only

STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Google Glass spectacles could offer tech giant new ways of harvesting data, says Andrew Keen
  • Keen argues that Glass raises further concerns over the way Google treats our private data
  • Wearing spectacles that record our every move could be the end of privacy as we know it, he says

Editor's note: Andrew Keen is a British-American entrepreneur, professional skeptic and the author of "The Cult of the Amateur" and "Digital Vertigo." Follow Andrew Keen on Twitter.

(CNN) -- It's hard to engineer this kind of creepy serendipity. Earlier this week, European Union data watchdogs, fighting to protect our privacy in an age of big data, put pressure on Google over the privacy of user information.

Just 48 hours later, Google potentially struck a new blow against privacy when it posted a video preview of its new "Glass" technology -- high-tech spectacles featuring a revolutionary digital interface that enable its wearers to not only view the world through Google's eyes but also automatically photograph all that they see.

"How strange is that!" CNN's Erin Burnett exclaimed after a contemplating a "world seen through Google Glasses".

Andrew Keen
Andrew Keen

Strange indeed. But these glasses, a kind of digital surrogate for our eyes, are strange in a creepy, Hitchcockian, "Rear Window" sort of way. Or the same way that Big Brother's ubiquitous cameras were strange in George Orwell's "Nineteen Eighty Four." And in the same way that a future in which "promethean" data companies like Google rule the world now appears strange.

The coincidental timing of last week's EU and Google announcements may have been unintentional, but it sure is ominous.

Read related: How it will feel to wear Google Glass

The EU is concerned about the way in which Google has, since last March, been pooling the data of its individual users across its popular services like search, Gmail, Google+ and YouTube in order to bundle them up for advertisers.

2012: Google develops 'smart glasses'
2012: Google's augmented reality glasses

Its anxiety over this aggregation of our personal information is twofold. Firstly, Google has done little, if anything, to inform users of this unilateral change. Secondly, Google hasn't offered users a way of opting out.

Google insists its privacy policies respect European laws and simply help enhance user experiences. But in the eyes of the EU, those of us using products like YouTube, Gmail or Google+ are being, to borrow a Microsoft coined neologism, "Scroogled" by Google's new privacy policy.

Last October, EU watchdogs gave Google four months to revise this policy. But last week, after nothing appeared to have changed, Brussels raised its warning a bureaucratic notch, promising to take action against Google by the summer.

And yet, in light of Google Glass, the EU's concerns seem like a quaint throwback to a more innocent digital age.

Watchdogs should, of course, be barking madly at Google's decision to pool our data for its advertising clients. Regardless of the legitimacy of such practices, I'm strongly in favor of making Google accountable, both legally and morally, for policies that so patently disregard the privacy of its users.

But Google Glass opens an entirely new front in the digital war against privacy. These spectacles, which have been specifically designed to record everything we see, represent a developmental leap in the history of data that is comparable to moving from the bicycle to the automobile.

It is the sort of radical transformation that may actually end up completely destroying our individual privacy in the digital 21st century.

Read related: From 3D graphics to biometric scans: How your smartphone will get smarter

When we put on these surveillance devices, we all become spies, or scrooglers, of everything and everyone around us.
Andrew Keen

While none of us were looking, Google -- the most data-hungry of today's digital giants -- is reengineering mobile technology. Thanks to Silicon Valley's mad rush to develop wearable computing, it isn't alone. Apple is supposedly working on its hotly-anticipated wristwatch and wearable personal data devices from companies like Nike and Fitbit are already beginning to revolutionize the healthcare industry.

But there's something particularly troubling about Google Glass. When we put on these surveillance devices, we all become spies, or scrooglers, of everything and everyone around us. By getting us to wear their all seeing digital eyeglasses, Google are metamorphosing us into human versions of those Street View vans -- now thankfully banned in Germany -- which crawl, like giant cockroaches, around our cities documenting our homes.

Neither Orwell nor Hitchcock at their most terrifyingly dystopian could have dreamt up Google Glass. According to Google co-founder Sergey Brin, quoted by tech website Mashable, "Glass will also have an automatic picture-taking mode, snapping pics at a preset intervals (such as every 5 seconds)."

Pics every 5 seconds! Gulp. So where will all that intimate data go? Erin Burnett's strange "world seen through Google Glasses" is actually, as another leading tech site Techcrunch notes "the world seen through Google's omnipresent eye."

And the terabytes of data sucked up every five seconds by its omniscient glasses will, of course, flow to Google. That's the whole business model, the very raison d'etre of Google Glass. Those pics every 5 seconds will be used to aggregate data and then to generate billions of dollars of revenue by selling advertising around it.

One EU complaint about current Google practice, you'll remember, was about the absence of an opt out button to enable users to say no to Google's pooling of their data.

But the problem of saying no, of opting out, becomes even more problematic with Google Glass. After all, as these Warby Parker or Ray-Ban-designed devices become more fashionable (ie: innocuous), most of us won't even know if we are being filmed when gazed at by a bespectacled stranger.

In pictures: 12 futuristic phone concepts

The EU watchdogs also objected to Google's current pooling of our data in a single personalized record. And Google Glass could, I fear, become the focal point for all our data in a world where privacy no longer exists.

"Everything, from Google searches to notifications to hangouts, seemingly happens in this one space," notes Techcrunch about the spectacles. Google Glass, thus, may become the pivotal post PC, post iPod and post tablet device. A pooling of all our most intimate data, a mirror of ourselves -- the holy grail, of course, for advertisers.

I remarked earlier that it's hard to engineer this creepy kind of serendipity. But I may have been wrong. You see, the whole point of Google Glass is actually to successfully engineer serendipity. The creepier, the better.

After all, when we wear these devices, those clever engineers at Google will know where we are all the time. So what's to stop them serving up personalized advertisements for products when the gaze of our glasses rest upon those products?

At the very moment we look at those new clothes in that store window, a special offer for the clothes will flash up on the digital interface of our Google Glass. How serendipitous, eh?

After all, when we wear these devices, those clever engineers at Google will know where we are all the time.
Andrew Keen

But what to do? Is there an antidote to Google's eyewear?

Google Glass is currently in being tested with plans for a finished product to be released into the mass market next year. Last week, Google announced that a few prototype models of the spectacles would go on sale for the not exactly bargain price of $1,500. To qualify, well-heeled Google fanboys need to go to their Google+ or Twitter accounts and, in 50 words or less, using the hashtag #ifihadglass, explain how they would use Google Glass.

So, if anyone at Google happens to be reading this, here's my application:

#ifihadglass: I would make data privacy its default feature. Nobody else sees the data I see unless I explicitly say so. Not advertisers, nor the government, and certainly not those engineers of the human soul at the Googleplex. No, Google Glass must be opaque. For my eyes only.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Andrew Keen.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
February 23, 2014 -- Updated 1705 GMT (0105 HKT)
Mobile World Congress offered up robotic balls, GPS walking sticks and more than its fair share of unexpected uses for digital technology.
February 28, 2013 -- Updated 1134 GMT (1934 HKT)
With many smartphone users groaning about battery performance, scientists are racing to design phones that never need to be charged.
February 27, 2013 -- Updated 1344 GMT (2144 HKT)
Nokia's wireless charging device is a pillow for your phone so that
3D screens, flamenco dancers and endless batteries: all the latest innovations being unveiled at Mobile World Congress in Barcelona.
February 27, 2013 -- Updated 1034 GMT (1834 HKT)
Yahoo's decision to curtail remote working has stirred dismay at a time when many companies are striving to enable telecommuting.
February 26, 2013 -- Updated 1630 GMT (0030 HKT)
The industry has repeatedly promised a "mobile advertising tipping point," but mobile advertising is yet to come of age.
February 26, 2013 -- Updated 2004 GMT (0404 HKT)
The 'phablet' seems to be MWC 2013's must-have item. This is the Asus Fonepad: A seven inch tablet with mobile phone capabilities. Samsung launched a similar product at the show called the Galaxy Note 8.0.
Didn't we tell you that the lines between smartphones and tablets are blurred? Case in point: the Asus Fonepad, a 7-inch tablet that's also a phone.
February 26, 2013 -- Updated 1725 GMT (0125 HKT)
In the not-too-distant future, you'll receive a full diagnosis and cure from your smartphone before you have even realized you're unwell.
February 25, 2013 -- Updated 1802 GMT (0202 HKT)
The next generation is just a few weeks away for the world's hottest smartphone without a piece of fruit on it.
February 25, 2013 -- Updated 1632 GMT (0032 HKT)
CNN's Kristie Lu Stout explores Barcelona, Spain -- home of the Mobile World Congress 2013 -- using only her smartphone.
February 22, 2013 -- Updated 1241 GMT (2041 HKT)
As CNN heads to Mobile World Congress 2013, we're asking readers what features they want to see on the phones of the future.
February 28, 2013 -- Updated 1632 GMT (0032 HKT)
Is it time to start carrying two mobile phones? At least one manufacturer is hoping more people might soon be relying on multiple mobiles.
February 26, 2013 -- Updated 0019 GMT (0819 HKT)
In the future we will have screens not just in the palm of our hands, but all around us, according to Google's Director of Android User Experience.
February 26, 2013 -- Updated 1423 GMT (2223 HKT)
Wearing spectacles that record our every move could be the end of privacy as we know it, says internet commentator Andrew Keen.
ADVERTISEMENT