Skip to main content

CNN Fact Check: What really happened in China tire case?

By the CNN Wire Staff
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 2158 GMT (0558 HKT)
  • The Chinese "were flooding us" with cheap tires, Obama says
  • "Gov. Romney criticized me for being too tough in that tire case"
  • Romney said Obama's action was "decidedly bad for the nation"

(CNN) -- In Monday's foreign policy debate, President Barack Obama said former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney had criticized his administration for being too tough against China and bringing a protectionist case at the World Trade Organization.

The statement: Obama cited a case in which the Chinese "were flooding us" with cheap tires. "And we put a stop to it and as a consequence saved jobs throughout America. I have to say that Gov. Romney criticized me for being too tough in that tire case; said this wouldn't be good for American workers and that it would be protectionist," Obama said.

CNN Fact Check: Romney, Obama and Iraq

The facts: In 2009, the Obama administration sought tariffs against China for dumping tires into the United States. The World Trade Organization upheld the tariffs.

On its website, Romney's campaign cites where the Republican candidate addressed the case in his 2010 book "No Apology."

"President Obama's action to defend American tire companies from foreign competition may make good politics by repaying unions for their support of his campaign, but it is decidedly bad for the nation and our workers," Romney said. "Protectionism stifles productivity."

Romney: I wouldn't hurt auto industry
Obama: 'We've made real progress'
Obama, Romney battle over foreign policy
The debate over Iran, horses & bayonets

The result was indeed inherently protectionist, according to Douglas Paal, vice president for studies at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

"It means it will raise prices for American consumers on tires, both domestic and imported," Paal said.

But the case was a minor one in the overall scheme of things, he added. Both sides have engaged in such symbolic activity, "but neither is willing to take action that would seriously affect economic relations between our two economies," he added.

CNN Fact Check: Comparing costs of Iraq, Libya missions

The subject of China has been raised over and over during the campaign, with each candidate accusing the Chinese of stealing American jobs through unfair trade practices.

In broad terms, both men offered similar views, even using some of the same language:

"China is both an adversary, but also a potential partner in the international community if it's following the rules," Obama said. "So my attitude coming into office was that we are going to insist that China plays by the same rules as everybody else."

"They're making some progress; they need to make more," said Romney, who vowed to label China a currency manipulator on his first day as president. "They have to understand we want to trade with them. We want a world that's stable. We like free enterprise, but you got to play by the rules."

First, has China really stolen U.S. jobs? The numbers say yes. Since China entered the World Trade Organization in 2001, the U.S. trade deficit with China "eliminated or displaced more than 2.7 million U.S. jobs," according to a report published in August by the Economic Policy Institute, a left-of-center think tank.

The primary category from which jobs have been lost has been in the manufacturing sector.

The candidates have complained because, while the United States allows the free market, in large part, to dictate how much a dollar is worth and how much people will be paid in the United States, China uses its power to keep wages low.

CNN Fact Check: Obama's apology tour?

So, while the Bureau of Labor Statistics says the average employer has to pay about $35 per hour in salary and benefits to hire a worker on a production line, a Chinese factory pays only about $1.36 per hour for the same work.

In response, many companies have moved jobs to China to take advantage of the lower wages. Consequently, Chinese products tend to be cheaper to buy all over the world.

The result has been that Chinese exports to the United States have soared in recent years, while U.S. exports to China have lagged far behind.

What can a U.S. president do about that?

Probably not much. If the United States were to raise trade barriers, China could do the same. If the United States were to forbid U.S.-based companies from shipping jobs to China, that might leave U.S. companies less competitive in the world market.

And if China were to say it is no longer interested in buying U.S. debt, that could make it harder for the U.S. government to borrow the money it needs to operate.

The conclusion: In the tire case above, Obama is correct in his characterization of Romney's position. In the larger case of what to do about U.S.-China relations, both candidates have promised to get tough. But that will hardly be the last word.

Complete coverage of CNN's Fact Checks

Part of complete coverage on
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 1458 GMT (2258 HKT)
Although it has been over for nearly a year now, the war in Iraq continued to be a flash point in the final debate.
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 1328 GMT (2128 HKT)
President Barack Obama made the case that al Qaeda in Pakistan is decimated while Mitt Romney argued they are on the rise in other countries.
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 1322 GMT (2122 HKT)
President Barack Obama accused Mitt Romney of initially being against a withdrawal of forces from Afghanistan in 2014.
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 1318 GMT (2118 HKT)
The contention that President Obama apologized to other nations for American behavior has been mentioned repeatedly by his critics, including Mitt Romney.
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 1312 GMT (2112 HKT)
President Barack Obama asserted that it cost the United States less to help oust Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi than it did to run two weeks of the 2003-2011 war in Iraq.
October 23, 2012 -- Updated 2158 GMT (0558 HKT)
President Barack Obama said Gov. Mitt Romney had criticized his administration for being too tough against China, and bringing a protectionist case at the World Trade Organization.
October 20, 2012 -- Updated 1648 GMT (0048 HKT)
Conservative critics launched an attack on moderator Candy Crowley after she corrected Romney's claim that Obama did not refer to the consulate attack in Benghazi as an "act of terror."
October 17, 2012 -- Updated 1150 GMT (1950 HKT)
Romney highlighted the number of women in the unemployment lines during President Barack Obama's term.
October 17, 2012 -- Updated 1630 GMT (0030 HKT)
Obama said he identified the September 11 assault on the U.S. Consulate in Libya as a terrorist attack within a day; Romney said it took two weeks.
October 17, 2012 -- Updated 1153 GMT (1953 HKT)
Obama touted his administration's support for the federal Pell Grant program and other aid for college students.
October 17, 2012 -- Updated 1151 GMT (1951 HKT)
Obama boasted that the Affordable Care Act gives insured women free contraception coverage, and said Romney thinks employers should decide whether women can get contraception through insurance.
October 12, 2012 -- Updated 1216 GMT (2016 HKT)
Fears of a possibly nuclear-armed Iran took center stage early in the vice presidential debate between Biden and Ryan.
October 12, 2012 -- Updated 1218 GMT (2018 HKT)
The September attack that killed four Americans at a U.S. diplomatic mission in Libya was the subject of a few claims at the VP debate.
October 12, 2012 -- Updated 1220 GMT (2020 HKT)
Federal support for wind power and electric cars was one of the early flashpoints between Biden and Ryan.
October 12, 2012 -- Updated 1215 GMT (2015 HKT)
The Affordable Care Act emerged as an issue between Vice President Joe Biden and Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis.