Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

Do open plan offices lead to better work or closed minds?

By Rose Hoare, for CNN
October 4, 2012 -- Updated 0521 GMT (1321 HKT)
Enjoying the wide open spaces? Facebook is set to build the world's largest open plan office.
Enjoying the wide open spaces? Facebook is set to build the world's largest open plan office.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Facebook plans to build world's largest open plan office
  • Popularity of open plan due to their adaptability
  • Some suggest they do not foster better communication or work
  • Unilever's open plan office in Hamburg, Germany, had three full time psychologists

(CNN) -- In August Facebook revealed that its new headquarters in California, designed by Frank Gehry, will be, according to company founder Mark Zuckerberg, "the largest open floor plan in the world".

Over 3,000 people will work on moveable furniture in a space that stretches over 10 acres.

But are open plan offices better suited to the machinations of architects and needs of a company rather than to employees?

Open plan offices came out of a drastic rethinking of architecture, by mid-20th century proponents like Frank Lloyd Wright (who thought walls were "fascist") and Frank Duffy.

In the 1960s, Robert Propst, a designer for Herman Miller, noticed people had their best ideas or did their best thinking when they left their desks.

Most people feel stressed when they first move to an open space. You don't have a private sphere anymore.
Karsten Ifversen, architecture editor, Politiken

His Action Office furniture, released in 1968, introduced cubicles to the world, in an attempt to revitalize a landscape that Propst had described as "the daily scene of unfulfilled intentions and failed effort."

Research by MIT professor Thomas Allen in 2006 discovered that people communicate the most with those in a 50 meter radius, and that complex topics are best discussed face to face.

But there are problems with open plan offices. According to a study by Berkeley researchers conducted over a decade, most workers find "speech privacy" the biggest problem. As a result some suggest that rather than foster more useful conversations they may actually inhibit them.

A 2000 study by Dana Johnson and Gary Evans suggested that the constant distraction of colleagues' noise dampens employees' motivation.

Even Propst revised his initial thoughts on cubicles. In a 1998 he said "crass people" had managed to use his idea to "create hellholes". "They make little bitty cubicles and stuff people in them. Barren, rat-hole places," he told Metropolis magazine.

Yet just as it did for an expanding postwar workforce, today, adjustable workspaces make economic sense and account for much of their enduring popularity.

"You can put more people together in the same space and fill it up without separating walls," says Karsten Ifversen, architecture editor for Danish newspaper Politiken. He adds that open plan designs also allow more light into deep buildings, and are cheaper to heat.

10 technologies that will change your workplace

"For employers, it's very easy to rearrange the workstations to account for changing needs. It is especially well suited for temporary types of work. You easily share information using an open space -- you get to know what's going on, if you're working on the same project," he says.

"The client likes to build them that way, and the architects like to draw them because you can get more dramatic spaces when you're operating with one big scale instead of having to make a lot of repetition of small spaces".

In some ways, an open plan makes an organization transparent to itself. You can see your colleagues, and they can see you.

"That is quite important, to feel some kind of unity," says Ifversen. "You're part of something bigger than yourself when you're working in the open space."

However Ifversen believes that open plan offices suit managers better than employees, and suggests that the problem of noise spillage goes deeper than merely finding it difficult to concentrate.

"Most people feel stressed when they first move to an open space. You don't have a private sphere anymore, so you can't personalize your workdesk in the same way. You're deprived of your individuality."

Are cool offices the key to success?

When employees moved into Unilever's new headquarters in Hamburg, Ifversen says, "they had three psychologists working full time for them, just to accommodate the problems around the new office."

Ifversen notes that (not unlike Facebook's influence on society), open plan "changes the balance between private and public".

"It's okay to watch YouTube clips or read irrelevant pages out in public," he says.

"All these human inclinations, there's no need to hide them. We accept it."

But for other human inclinations -- such as the inclination to fight -- private space is still a necessity, says Ifversen. "You have to have a room where you can go and have an argument without everybody listening in. It's a problem if a building can't accommodate that."

8 ways to make your office life better

Like Propst, he believes workspaces should encourage creative thought, but he believes this is being addressed in a patronizing way -- "they have all these entertaining rooms, with perhaps a playground."

A more important consideration is to make employees feel important, "to somehow empower the employee so they feel that they are necessary for the product."

Ifversen believes an open plan office "sends a signal that you are interchangeable", and argues that, if employees don't have dedicated spaces they can personalize, they are more likely to feel that their job is temporary. "I think that is kind of a sad development."

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
October 29, 2012 -- Updated 0256 GMT (1056 HKT)
If you find yourself giving off a sunnier disposition when your boss is smiling, it might be because your brain is wired to do so.
November 8, 2012 -- Updated 0325 GMT (1125 HKT)
Employees want to work for the good guys and if companies want to attract and keep top talent, corporate social responsibility matters.
November 2, 2012 -- Updated 1249 GMT (2049 HKT)
Bill Clinton had a coach, Oprah Winfrey used one to help her get to the top of her career and, of course, top sports stars have them.
September 22, 2012 -- Updated 1437 GMT (2237 HKT)
Co-working spaces are on the rise in Asia where rents, and a desire to collaborate, are high.
From 'gameification' to virtual reality Google glasses, check out the top 10 tech coming to an office near you soon.
September 14, 2012 -- Updated 0413 GMT (1213 HKT)
In 2009, Lu Qi, an author of martial arts novels, published his first book on a slightly different type of combat sport: office politics in China.
August 31, 2012 -- Updated 0311 GMT (1111 HKT)
What to do with gossiping colleagues, smelly lunches and when the boss has your number.
August 27, 2012 -- Updated 0450 GMT (1250 HKT)
Perplexing power structures and Confucianism could be stifling China's creative businesses.
From dogs and plants to turning off your devices, we highlight eight ways to make office life better.
August 21, 2012 -- Updated 0621 GMT (1421 HKT)
It could be out with old meeting rooms and in with new social spaces, as Generation Y is set to transform the way we work in the next ten years.
August 10, 2012 -- Updated 0930 GMT (1730 HKT)
View the gallery of some of the worl's most spectacular and wacky offices.
August 10, 2012 -- Updated 1442 GMT (2242 HKT)
in the 1980s, more than a sharp suit or a beautiful secretary, having a nice office meant you had arrived. Is it stil the case?
August 10, 2012 -- Updated 0724 GMT (1524 HKT)
You're in your 'swim lane' and the 'tiger team' is on the way. Are you stumped or ready for business?
ADVERTISEMENT