Skip to main content

Amanda Knox freed, but truth about student's slaying elusive

By Richard Allen Greene, CNN
October 4, 2011 -- Updated 0936 GMT (1736 HKT)
Amanda Knox on Monday was cleared in the murder of her roommate in Italy, nearly four years after she was arrested.
Amanda Knox on Monday was cleared in the murder of her roommate in Italy, nearly four years after she was arrested.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Knox was cleared in the 2007 death of her roommate
  • The defense maintains prosecutors can't prove her involvement
  • Knox spent four years behind bars

Perugia, Italy (CNN) -- Who is Amanda Knox?

Is she a two-faced she-devil, angelic and compassionate to some but Satanic and Lucifer-like to others?

That's what Carlo Pacelli, the lawyer for a man Knox falsely accused in the 2007 murder of her roommate, Meredith Kercher, called her as he summed up his case last week.

Is she "Foxy Knoxy," as the British tabloid press leered and sneered at her within hours of her exoneration in Kercher's murder Monday?

Or is she the fresh-faced girl from Seattle she still appears to be, even after spending nearly four years behind bars before her conviction was quashed?

Was Italy fair to Amanda Knox?
Social media buzzing over Knox ruling
'Joy' in Seattle as Knox set free
Who was Meredith Kercher?

Is Knox simply the victim of character assassination, painted falsely as a "femme fatale" by prosecutors and media the world over? Defense lawyer Giulia Bongiorno advanced that theory in her own closing argument. She compared Knox to Jessica Rabbit, the hourglass-shaped, husky-voiced cartoon character who insists in the movie "Who Framed Roger Rabbit?" that she's not bad, she's just "drawn that way."

Five women and three men on a jury here weighed in decisively on who Knox is Monday, throwing out the five most serious charges she was originally convicted of in connection with Kercher's death and releasing her from prison.

Audible gasp in courtroom as verdict is read

The jury also freed Raffaele Sollecito, her former boyfriend who became her co-defendant.

Their release came at the end of an appeal lasting just over four months and feeling much more like a re-trial than an appeal as understood in the United States or Kercher's native Britain.

Lawyers battled on two fronts -- DNA evidence and Knox's character.

Police scientists argued that a knife found at Sollecito's home had traces of Kercher's DNA on the blade and Knox's DNA on the handle. And they testified that a bra clasp belonging to Kercher and found in her room had Sollecito's genetic material on it.

Experts appointed by the court questioned police handling of the evidence, suggesting authorities' sloppiness could make the DNA results unreliable and should make them inadmissible in court.

Prosecution witnesses, meanwhile, maintained that the tests were valid -- leading to highly technical and sometimes heated courtroom arguments and prompting the prosecution to ask for new DNA tests, a request the judge rejected.

No end to Knox as pop culture obsession

Knox and Sollecito do not have airtight alibis for the night of November 1, 2007, when Kercher's throat was slashed, her semi-naked body left under a bed cover.

Their cell phones and Sollecito's computer were switched off at the time of the murder, depriving them of potentially exculpatory evidence.

But while they cannot prove they were not at the scene of the crime, their defense team says the prosecution cannot prove that they were. There was no physical trace of them in the room where Kercher died, Knox and Sollecito's lawyers insisted.

They argued that the crime was solely the work of drifter Rudy Guede, who was convicted separately and is serving 16 years. His DNA was all over the crime scene, the defense said.

That may have been enough for the jury to set Knox and Sollecito free.

Defense lawyer Luciano Ghirga reminded the jury repeatedly Monday morning that the prosecution needed to prove its case "beyond a reasonable doubt" -- a standard he made a point of saying was rooted in Italian law and was not imported from America, in a nod to the nationalistic tensions that have sometimes seemed to underpin this case.

The jury must have had sufficient doubts to overturn a verdict rendered by eight of their compatriots less than two years ago. That means that either Knox and Sollecito were the victims of a miscarriage of justice then, or that Kercher is now.

Only Knox and Sollecito themselves may know which it is -- because nearly four years after Kercher's death, incontrovertible evidence about whether Knox and Sollecito were involved remains maddeningly elusive.

CNN's Hada Messia and Mallory Simon contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
The Knox/Sollecito retrial
January 31, 2014 -- Updated 1152 GMT (1952 HKT)
Student Amanda Knox and her former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito are waiting -- once again -- for a verdict from an Italian court.
November 6, 2013 -- Updated 1334 GMT (2134 HKT)
Amanda Knox's former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito took the stand in an Italian court, defending himself.
November 2, 2013 -- Updated 2158 GMT (0558 HKT)
CNN's Fredricka Whitfield talks with Steve Moore about discrepancies he found in the Amanda Knox case.
October 2, 2013 -- Updated 1609 GMT (0009 HKT)
Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito were not in the Florentine appellate court Monday for the opening day of their appeal.
October 3, 2013 -- Updated 0229 GMT (1029 HKT)
Amanda Knox's former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito talks about his life now and the new Meredith Kercher murder trial.
March 28, 2013 -- Updated 1436 GMT (2236 HKT)
How come Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito are back to square one in the Meredith Kercher murder trial?
March 26, 2013 -- Updated 1547 GMT (2347 HKT)
amanda knox file
CNN senior legal analyst Jeff Toobin weighs in on an Italian court's decision to retry Amanda Knox for murder.
January 30, 2014 -- Updated 1343 GMT (2143 HKT)
Since her release from an Italian prison, Amanda Knox has been trying to stay out of the public eye back in her hometown, Seattle.
January 29, 2014 -- Updated 1756 GMT (0156 HKT)
British student Meredith Kercher was found dead in November 2007. Six years on, two defendants are told they face a retrial.
January 31, 2014 -- Updated 0556 GMT (1356 HKT)
A look back at the key players in the trial of Amanda Knox.
January 30, 2014 -- Updated 1342 GMT (2142 HKT)
Raffaele Sollecito, right, attends his appeal hearing
Raffaele Sollecito says the discovery of Meredith Kercher's body was the start of a nightmare. Now he wants a normal life back, he says.
ADVERTISEMENT